If you find yourself stuck in your own mind, overanalyzing every situation, conversation, decision, outfit and meal you’ve eaten…you’re not alone. Maybe you’ve been told by others that you’re “too in your head,” that you’re an ‘overthinker’ or that you intellectualize everything. And deep down, you agree—but you’re not sure what to do about it.
If you’re anything like most of my clients and myself at some points, you might feel disconnected from your emotions, as though they’re locked away somewhere you can’t quite reach. As a high-achieving, perfectionistic woman, you likely excel at problem-solving and critical thinking, but when it comes to your feelings, it’s like you just can’t access them. If this resonates with you, EMDR therapy could be exactly what you need to bridge the gap between your mind and body.
Start EMDR TherapyUnderstanding Why We Overthink
Many women that I work with who are high achievers rely on their intellect as a way to navigate the world. This makes sense—your ability to analyze and solve problems has likely been a source of success and recognition. For myself, teachers and my father praised me for my intellect and connected with me over books, writing, and interest in the arts.
But sometimes, this very helpful skill of intellectualizing can become a barrier. Overthinking is often a way to avoid feeling vulnerable emotions. Instead of sitting with discomfort, you might analyze it, trying to understand or rationalize your way out of it.
This might look like you being able to talk about your childhood trauma till your blue in the face without shedding a tear, but then finding yourself in the midst of an anxiety attack when you get caught in traffic on your way to work.
As noted above, not feeling your feelings is a coping mechanism that may have roots in past experiences. Perhaps you grew up in an environment where feelings weren’t validated or where being strong and self-sufficient was the only option. This adaptive skill could have worked to save your life or protect you from drowning in feelings that you were too young and vulnerable to process on your own. This was incredibly smart and scrappy of you!
Over time, you probably learned that staying in your head felt safer than allowing emotions to surface. The problem is, this disconnect from your emotions can lead to anxiety, self-criticism, and even physical symptoms like tension, fatigue, or digestive issues (your unfelt emotions may literally be making you sick!).
Schedule A Free ConsultHow EMDR Therapy Works
EMDR, or Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, is a powerful therapy designed to help you process and heal from past experiences that are still affecting you today. Unlike traditional talk therapy, EMDR doesn’t require you to “talk it all out” or figure out every detail of what’s bothering you. Instead, it focuses on helping your brain and body work together to process stuck memories and beliefs.
Here’s how it works: During an EMDR session, you’ll focus on a specific memory or belief while engaging in bilateral stimulation, such as following a moving object with your eyes or tapping alternately on each hand. This process helps your brain reprocess the memory, reducing the emotional charge it carries and allowing you to integrate it in a healthier way.
Why EMDR Therapy Is Awesome for Women Who Intellectualize
If you’re someone who intellectualizes, EMDR can help you bypass the mental overanalysis and connect more directly with your emotions. Here’s why it’s so effective:
- A Body-Based Approach: EMDR works with the body’s natural processing system. Even if you’re not fully aware of your emotions, your body remembers them. EMDR taps into that stored information, helping you release it without needing to fully verbalize or rationalize it.
- Breaking the Loop: For overthinkers, it’s easy to get stuck in a cycle of “why am I like this?” or “what’s wrong with me?” EMDR interrupts this cycle, allowing your brain to process and resolve the underlying issues instead of looping through them endlessly.
- Gentle and Gradual: EMDR meets you where you are. You don’t need to have all the answers or even fully understand what’s causing your distress. The process helps uncover and resolve layers of experience in a way that feels manageable and safe. Furthermore, when combined with a compassionate approach like IFS, it allows your parts to guide the show in a way that allows them to feel seen and comfortable.
The Benefits of EMDR Therapy for Overthinkers
The women I work with who have gone through EMDR often report feeling lighter and more grounded. They describe a sense of clarity and calm that wasn’t accessible before. Here are just a few ways EMDR can transform your life:
- Reduced Anxiety: Instead of being stuck in an endless loop of overthinking, you’ll feel more present and able to engage with life.
- Greater Emotional Awareness: You’ll begin to notice and honor your emotions instead of brushing them aside or analyzing them away.
- Improved Self-Compassion: EMDR can help quiet your inner critic and replace it with a kinder, more understanding voice.
- Physical Relief: Many clients experience reduced physical symptoms like muscle tension, headaches, or stomach issues as they release stored emotional stress.
A Path to Deeper Connection
As you work through EMDR, you’ll start to reconnect with parts of yourself that have been buried under layers of overthinking and self-criticism. You might find it easier to set boundaries, communicate your needs, and truly relax. Heck, I’ve had clients leave abusive marriages, quit awful jobs and start their own businesses, or decide to travel the world.
Most importantly, EMDR will help you begin to trust yourself and your emotions in a way that feels deeply empowering.
Ready to Take the Next Step?
If you’re tired of feeling disconnected from your emotions and overwhelmed by your own thoughts, EMDR therapy could be the change you’ve been searching for. You don’t have to keep carrying the weight of anxiety, self-doubt, and overthinking on your own.
Let’s work together to help you find relief and reconnect with yourself in a way that feels authentic and lasting. Schedule your free 20-minute consultation today, and let’s explore how EMDR can support you on your journey to healing.
Begin EMDR Therapy*************************************
Emma Kobil is a licensed professional counselor practicing online in Colorado and Florida. Her philosophically informed therapeutic approach focuses on helping creative and perfectionist women practice self compassion. Learn more about Emma, or schedule an appointment, at mindfulcounselingdenver.com.